Commerce for growing businesses
Magento vs Shopify for wholesale and retail
Shopify provides a managed commerce platform; Magento and Adobe Commerce setups differ by edition and deployment. A move is worthwhile only if the new setup can preserve valuable dealer pricing, approvals and custom logic at an acceptable total cost. Start with the system you actually run.[1][10]
When Magento fits
Staying can make sense when your existing custom logic, negotiated quotes and purchasing approvals work well, and the team can maintain them at an acceptable cost.
When Shopify fits
Consider Shopify when a tested setup can preserve those buying rules while reducing the platform work your team carries. Moving only makes sense if the operational benefits justify the rebuild.
The practical comparison
Compare the work behind the platform.
Look at the capabilities, the dependencies, and who will own the work. Source links sit beside each comparison.
| What matters | ||
|---|---|---|
| Hosting and upgrades[1][10] | Adobe PaaS and on-premises require planned upgrades. Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service updates automatically. Identify the existing deployment before comparing maintenance. | Shopify manages the hosted platform and its updates. Your team still owns store configuration, apps and integration behavior. |
| Each reseller’s products and prices[3][6] | Adobe Commerce B2B supports company-specific shared catalogs. Check the extensions supplying equivalent behavior in a Magento Open Source store. | Basic, Grow and Advanced allow three active catalog assignments across B2B markets. Plus supports unlimited assignments and direct company/location catalogs. |
| Reorders and pack quantities[4][7] | Requisition lists let Adobe Commerce buyers keep frequently purchased items ready for another order. | Catalog quantity rules and volume pricing can enforce buying increments and price breaks. Test case, unit and pallet definitions against warehouse records. |
| Quotes and approval[5][8] | Authorized buyers and reps can negotiate quotes, exchanging quantities, prices and comments before acceptance. | B2B draft orders support assisted purchases and review before acceptance. A draft-order review is not automatically equivalent to a complex purchasing approval tree. |
| Custom extensions[1][10] | Adobe PaaS/on-premises support PHP extensions; Adobe SaaS uses a different extensibility model. Preserve the behavior that matters, not every old extension. | Map required behavior to Shopify configuration, apps or supported extensions. Validate special pricing, product options and operational connections before choosing the build. |
| Cost of keeping it working[11] | Compare the actual hosting, licensing, development, support and integration bills for your deployment. | Include the required plan, apps, payment charges, implementation and ongoing support. A vendor’s average cost advantage is not your savings forecast. |
How the work connects
Preserve the buying rules, wherever the order runs.
- Company buyer
- Shared catalog
- Negotiated quote
- Accepted order
- Company location
- Assigned catalog
- Draft review if needed
- Accepted order
Test a dealer’s reorder to a different branch.
Use a redacted past order and the dealer’s current agreement. Ask the rep and warehouse to review the same test.
Identify the buyer
Confirm which branches they may order for, then apply the selected location’s products, prices and eligible terms.
Price the actual delivery
Validate case quantities and the packed pallet load. Recheck freight for the new destination, unloading needs and supported carrier service.
Confirm the handoff
Find the accepted order in the agreed operational system using the buyer’s PO. Check quantities, prices and that it arrived once.
Test the exception. If the load cannot be rated or a price needs approval, hold it for review. Pending freight must remain visibly pending; it must not become free shipping.
Your numbers, your comparison
What would each option cost you?
A licence is one part of the cost. Add your actual quotes and operating estimates to compare the same scope.
0 of 8 estimates entered
Complete both platforms to see totals and a proportional cost breakdown.
First-year total = 12 × monthly costs + one-off implementation.
Planning estimates, not vendor quotes. Excludes tax, payment-related variable fees, hardware, and financing. The three-year view assumes unchanged monthly costs and one implementation charge.
Before you move
Make the decision with your real workflow.
Use these checks with your team and implementation partner. A useful demo should answer them with your products, people, and exceptions.
Plan a Shopify migration Discuss your setupProve the difficult order
Include a restricted SKU, a changed branch and a rep-negotiated exception. A normal retail checkout does not test dealer purchasing.
Map the useful custom logic
Record what each extension does, its proposed replacement and a pass condition. Keep working behavior that would be expensive to recreate.
Compare a complete operating budget
Include migration, parallel operation, required tools and ongoing ownership. Use your contracts and workload instead of a generic savings percentage.
Operating in Canada
Test a Canadian dealer’s agreed CAD price and delivery branch. Include a receiving location without a dock, and confirm the freight review path and currency on the final order.
Operating in the United States
Test a US distributor with several branches, restricted assortments and assigned reps. Confirm who can order for each branch and how an exception reaches the responsible person.
Questions before switching
The details worth asking.
Are Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce the same comparison?
Do we need Shopify Plus for wholesale?
Not for every setup. The standard plans support native B2B with limited market catalog assignments. Direct catalogs for individual companies or locations, and unlimited assignments, require Plus. Map the reseller agreements before selecting the plan.
[6]Can reps keep handling negotiated orders?
Does moving remove our upgrade work?
Can we use the same checkout features for wholesale and retail?
Check compatibility rather than assuming parity. Shopify B2B excludes accelerated checkouts such as Shop Pay and has other limitations, including subscriptions. A consumer checkout conversion claim does not demonstrate the experience for an approved trade buyer.
[9]How do Magento and Shopify compare on total cost of ownership?
Possibly, but the decision needs your numbers. Include development, support, payments, apps and migration, alongside platform fees. Shopify’s published TCO research is commissioned enterprise research; it is useful context, not a guaranteed reduction for your business.
[11]Check the evidence
Sources & further reading
Reviewed November 16, 2026. Plans, pricing, and availability can change. Confirm the exact configuration with each provider before buying.
- Adobe Commerce deployment comparison (opens in a new tab)
SaaS, PaaS and on-premises distinctions; updated November 11, 2026.
- Shopify’s Adobe Commerce comparison (opens in a new tab)
Vendor comparison; check deployment-specific claims against Adobe documentation.
- Shopify TCO study and methodology (opens in a new tab)
Shopify-commissioned research, December 2023–January 2024; 250 US/Canadian enterprises with revenue of at least $10M.
