Commerce for growing businesses
BigCommerce vs Shopify
BigCommerce B2B Edition and Shopify both support trade buying, with different account, quote and plan requirements. Compare the setup that preserves your buyer agreements and improves daily operations. A lower subscription price alone does not establish a better fit.[1][6]
When BigCommerce fits
B2B Edition, company hierarchies, quoting or your existing storefront architecture already fit the business. A move should solve a clear problem before replacing that investment.
When Shopify fits
A tested Shopify configuration improves the way your team runs retail and online commerce, without losing the trade purchasing and integrations buyers rely on.
The practical comparison
Compare the work behind the platform.
Look at the capabilities, the dependencies, and who will own the work. Source links sit beside each comparison.
| What matters | ||
|---|---|---|
| Self-serve B2B[1][6] | B2B Edition supports company accounts, buyer roles, invoices and assisted purchasing. Compare the edition you actually have. | Native B2B starts on Basic, with plan-dependent catalog and payment features. Validate the proposed portal against existing buyer tasks. |
| Companies & branches[2][6] | B2B Edition supports company hierarchies and permission-controlled buying for subsidiaries. | Company locations can represent branches. Prove the permission model; direct company/location catalogs require Plus. |
| Negotiated quotes[3][6] | B2B Edition quotes can include agreed line prices, shipping and expiry. Preserve the rules your sales team uses. | Map quote negotiation, approval and expiry to the proposed native or app workflow. A draft order is not proof of complete parity. |
| Payments & growth costs[4][8] | Current self-service plans have sales-volume rules and provider-dependent fees. Embedded and Open Payment Providers have different treatment. | Check the plan, payment provider and applicable transaction charges. Use your written terms and expected order mix for both sides. |
| Retail & online[5][9] | Review the current POS connection, stock ownership and return handling. A working integration may already fit the business. | Shopify POS shares the commerce platform. Test receiving, location stock and cross-channel returns, including any extra retail tools. |
| Catalog & integrations[5] | Document product options, modifiers, storefront differences and connected ERP behavior before replacing them. | Use sample products and orders to prove the new model. Budget separately for integrations and any behavior that needs rebuilding. |
How the work connects
Preserve the agreement behind the order.
- Buyer & subsidiary
- Quote & catalog price
- Invoice & rep ownership
- Permissions verified
- Terms reproduced
- Records reconciled
A school orders sixty units. A parent orders one.
Use one catalog with two different buying journeys. The institutional buyer needs purchasing terms; the retail buyer needs a simple checkout.
Recognize the account
Place the institutional buyer under the correct organization and branch. Keep negotiated terms out of the public retail experience.
Approve a quote
Apply agreed quantities, pricing, expiry and delivery. Make it clear which changes need sales approval.
Confirm the shipment
Separate a parcel from a pallet order. Validate access requirements and the final freight amount before acceptance.
Keep sales informed
Send the PO and account context to operations and the CRM. Preserve the rep owner and assign any unresolved delivery question.
Test the exception. Test an expired quote, a buyer from the wrong branch and a failed ERP handoff. Each needs a visible response and a responsible person.
Your numbers, your comparison
What would each option cost you?
A licence is one part of the cost. Add your actual quotes and operating estimates to compare the same scope.
0 of 8 estimates entered
Complete both platforms to see totals and a proportional cost breakdown.
First-year total = 12 × monthly costs + one-off implementation.
Planning estimates, not vendor quotes. Excludes tax, payment-related variable fees, hardware, and financing. The three-year view assumes unchanged monthly costs and one implementation charge.
Before you move
Make the decision with your real workflow.
Use these checks with your team and implementation partner. A useful demo should answer them with your products, people, and exceptions.
Plan a Shopify migration Discuss your setupCompare the real B2B editions
List required hierarchy, catalog, quote and invoice behavior. Match each requirement to the proposed plan and configuration before comparing subscription prices.
Read the payment agreement
Classify actual orders by provider and contract. Include any sales-volume or provider fees, payment processing and the effect of growing sales.
Prove the awkward product
Test the item with modifiers, pack sizes, restricted visibility or unusual freight. Follow it through the ERP and any separate storefront before signing off.
Operating in Canada
Compare CAD operating budgets, with USD subscriptions converted consistently by your finance team. Test negotiated dealer prices independently of country pricing, and run a Canadian pallet order through the carrier and accounting setup.
Operating in the United States
Use the actual payment contract and expected sales volume. Test procurement POs, approved resale treatment, branch access and LTL delivery conditions. A national catalog still needs rules for individual reseller agreements.
Questions before switching
The details worth asking.
Is Shopify better than BigCommerce for wholesale?
Both can serve wholesale buyers. BigCommerce B2B Edition has substantial company, quote and invoice capabilities. Shopify can be a good fit for combined retail and trade operations when the chosen plan and apps meet the requirements. Compare a complete purchasing journey rather than a feature count.
[1][6]Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?
A blanket “no fees” statement is misleading. Current Core, Growth and Scale pricing distinguishes Embedded Payment Providers from Open Payment Providers, with fees for eligible open-provider orders. Performance uses contracted terms. Confirm the current definitions, your provider and any processing charges before calculating savings.
[4]Which is cheaper: BigCommerce or Shopify?
Can Shopify preserve our company hierarchy and quote process?
Can retail and B2B buyers share one Shopify store?
A blended store can support both, with the appropriate account, catalog and checkout configuration. Trade access, pricing and freight should be tested separately from retail. Also review Shopify’s B2B feature exclusions before assuming every retail app or checkout feature works for company orders.
[7]When should we stay on BigCommerce?
Stay when the current implementation supports the business well and the proposed move does not solve a measurable problem. Improving catalog navigation, a slow integration or buyer onboarding can be a smaller and more valuable project than replacing the platform.
Check the evidence
Sources & further reading
Reviewed November 16, 2026. Plans, pricing, and availability can change. Confirm the exact configuration with each provider before buying.
- BigCommerce pricing and payment-provider terms (opens in a new tab)
Confirm sales-volume rules and the current contract.
- Shopify: BigCommerce comparison (opens in a new tab)
Vendor perspective. Its average research outcomes are not used as savings forecasts.
